Consistency

When-Then Plans: The Easiest Way to Actually Do Your Workouts

One sentence, written down, is one of the most effective tools in behavior science. Here's how to use it.

Key takeaways

  • An implementation intention is a plan in the form: "When situation X happens, I will do Y."
  • In one study, 91% of people who made such a plan exercised, versus around 35 to 38% of the others (Milne et al., 2002).
  • A review of 94 studies found a medium to large effect on reaching goals (Gollwitzer & Sheeran, 2006).
  • Add an if-then backup for obstacles: "If it rains, I'll do the home workout."

The experiment

In 2002, psychologists Sarah Milne, Sheina Orbell and Paschal Sheeran split 248 young adults into three groups:

  1. A control group that just read something unrelated.
  2. A motivation group that read about the health benefits of exercise.
  3. A motivation plus plan group that read the same text and then completed one sentence: "During the next week, I will partake in at least 20 minutes of vigorous exercise on [day] at [time of day] at/in [place]."

Over the next week, about 38% of the control group and 35% of the motivation group exercised. In the group that wrote the sentence, 91% did (Milne et al., 2002).

Motivation alone didn't change anything. A single, specific sentence nearly tripled follow-through.

Why it works

When you decide in advance when and where, the situation itself becomes the trigger. You don't have to remember, weigh options or find the energy to decide. "It's Monday at 6 pm and I'm leaving the office" automatically leads to "I'm going to the gym."

Psychologist Peter Gollwitzer describes it as passing control of the behavior to the environment. A review of 94 studies found these plans reliably help people reach goals, from exercise to healthy eating (Gollwitzer & Sheeran, 2006).

How to write a good when-then plan

A good plan has three parts: when, where and what.

Weak planStrong plan
I'll work out more.Monday, Wednesday, Friday at 6:15 pm I'll do my workout at the gym next to the office.
I'll eat healthier.When I get home from work, I'll eat the dinner I prepped on Sunday.
I'll walk more.After lunch, I'll walk around the block for 15 minutes.

Tips:

  • Use a cue you can't miss. "After I drop the kids at school" or "when I close my laptop" works better than "in the evening."
  • Be specific about the place. "The gym on Main Street" beats "the gym."
  • Write it down. In the study, people physically wrote the sentence.
  • Put it in your calendar. Treat it like a meeting.

Add if-then plans for obstacles

The second level is planning for what will go wrong. Think about the two or three things that usually stop you, and make a backup:

  • If I have to work late, then I'll do the 20-minute version at home.
  • If it's raining, then I'll do my run on the treadmill.
  • If I'm too tired after work, then I'll just go and do the first two exercises.
  • If friends invite me out for dinner, then I'll pick a protein-rich main and skip the second drink.

These "coping plans" keep one obstacle from cancelling the whole session.

When-then plans for eating

Food decisions happen many times a day, which makes them perfect for implementation intentions:

  • When I do my weekly grocery shopping, I'll buy what's on my meal plan list.
  • When I get hungry in the afternoon, I'll eat the yogurt and fruit I packed.
  • When I eat out, I'll order a dish with a clear protein source.

Combine this with a weekly meal plan and grocery list and most daily food decisions disappear.

Templates you can copy

Gym after work "On Monday, Wednesday and Friday, when I leave the office at 5:30 pm, I go straight to the gym on Main Street and do my workout."

Morning at home "On Tuesday, Thursday and Saturday, after my first coffee, I do my 30-minute home workout in the living room."

Lunch break "On Monday and Thursday at 12:30, I take my gym bag and train at the gym next to the office for 40 minutes."

Coping plans

  • "If I'm still at work at 6 pm, then I do the 20-minute version at home."
  • "If my partner needs the car, then I bike to the gym."
  • "If I'm tired, then I do just the first two exercises and decide after."

Why writing it down matters

It might feel unnecessary to write a sentence you already know. But in the original study, the act of writing the plan in a specific format was the intervention. Writing forces you to decide the details: which days, what time, which place. Vague intentions leave room for "later." Specific plans don't.

Checking your plan

A good plan passes this test: could someone else tell exactly where you'll be and what you'll do at that moment? If the answer is "probably at the gym sometime in the evening," make it more specific.

Frequently asked questions

What is an implementation intention?

A specific plan in the form "When situation X arises, I will perform behavior Y." It links a goal to a concrete cue, so the behavior starts more automatically.

Do when-then plans work long term?

They're strongest in the first weeks, when habits haven't formed yet. Over time, repeating the plan in the same situation turns it into a habit, which is exactly the goal.

How many plans should I make?

Start with one or two. Too many plans at once can be confusing. One for training days and one for your biggest obstacle is a great start.

Sources

  1. Milne S, Orbell S, Sheeran P. Combining motivational and volitional interventions to promote exercise participation: Protection motivation theory and implementation intentions. British Journal of Health Psychology. 2002;7(2):163-184.
  2. Gollwitzer PM, Sheeran P. Implementation intentions and goal achievement: A meta-analysis of effects and processes. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology. 2006;38:69-119.
  3. Gollwitzer PM. Implementation intentions: Strong effects of simple plans. American Psychologist. 1999;54(7):493-503.
Written by Timur Leontyev

Founder of Buffd. Every guide is based on peer-reviewed research, with sources listed so you can check them yourself.

This guide is general information for healthy adults, not medical advice. If you have a health condition, are pregnant or take medication, talk to a doctor first.

Join the beta on TestFlight